IN: Reviews

Beatrice Rana Glows in Heartfelt Interpretations


Holding her Celebrity Series audience rapt, pianist Beatrice Rana treated Jordan Hall to singular Debussy, Bach, and Beethoven. Her entrance drew more than a few gasps, as she glided on stage in an iridescent black gown with an hourglass silhouette and a unique embroidered back reminiscent of a swan’s wings.

In the seven interlinked keyboard miniatures constituting Bach’s French Suite No.2, BMV 813, employing artful pedal changes— sometimes fluttering, sometimes funneling— Rana sketched a series of highly stylized dance scenes. Set in the home key of C minor, the suite consists of an elegant Allemande in binary form, a nimble Courante, a gentle Sarabande, an Air, an elegantly wrought pair of Minuets, and a butterfly-light Gigue (jig) that was perhaps more curious than joyful.

Rana’s refined yet unpretentious approach to these dance miniatures offered a refreshing change from the many proficient takes on this work that exhibit tempo but no heartbeat, intelligence but no humor. The warmth of her tone, partnered with the elastic energy of her counterpoint, recalled the human origins of dance in continuous movement and the body. Too often Bach is treated like a musical chessboard, a lonely intellectual game. Beatrice shows how the music found in these suites can also be a colorful dance floor.

After a pause, as though appreciating a beautiful gift, Rana unwrapped Debussy’s Pour le piano. Composed in the period 1895-1901 after a hiatus writing for opera and orchestra (including the orchestral Nocturnes and Pelléas et Mélisande), Pour le piano is a treasure trove of glissandi, celestial perpetual-motion effects, and gossamer trills. In these highly experimental and individualistic tone poems, Debussy tests the boundaries of keyboard writing and of his own style: behind him are such confections as the Deux Arabesques and the Rêverie, and ahead are Images, Estampes, L’Isle Joyeux, the Préludes, and the Études.

Rana took listeners on a joyride through different tonal and pianistic possibilities, a journey that started with the extroverted Prélude.The swirling rhythms came brilliantly to life: on display too were diamond-like ornamentation and layering, evaporating whole-tone scales, hypnotic pedal points, and mellifluous Javanese gongs.

In the Sarabande, Rana took on a more meditative and aloof aspect, seemingly lost in the composer’s luminous and misty landscapes. Debussy remarked that this section should be “rather like an old portrait in the Louvre,” a velvety nostalgia that Rana captured well. The third and last movement, a Toccata, arrived in bright energetic swirls, which through a series of insouciant turns and Scarlatti-like runs shifted into a disarmingly poignant melody.

Following a brief intermission, Rana plunged into the fortissimi of Beethoven’s Hammerklavier. Acerbic, convex, unsightly, and neurotic, this challenging and grotesque sonata — completed in 1818, when the master was stone deaf — registered as a brusque antipode to Debussy’s sweet digressions. While Rana’s delivery of the Allegro and Scherzo were powerful, in the Adagio Sostenuto she exhibited a level of restraint that I have never witnessed in this sonata, bringing out the inexorable and the terrifying via time-defying extremes of tempo and dynamics. In this section, which has been described as a “mausoleum of collective suffering,” Rana’s increasingly fine pianissimi and carefully calibrated ritardando evoked frost creeping over a windowpane. Time stood still as the anxieties and morbid fantasies of the exposition metastasized into a haunted silence, a space of negative capability sustained by Rana’s restraint and vulnerable pathos. People were seen weeping.

The finale arrived almost secretly, as a seamless continuation of the Adagio. Some members of the audience may not have realized that a transition between movements had occurred. Rana cast the exploratory opening octaves like tentative beams of light, a gradual awakening and reckoning that culminated in the fury and conceptual density of the fugue. Here Rana’s athletistry and contrapuntal intelligence both came to the battlefield, rising triumphantly to meet Beethoven’s intense technical and artistic demands.

There was an audible “wow” before the  applause, which Rana rewarded with a delicate rendition of “The Swan” by Saint-Saëns/Godowksy. Coaxed back to the stage seven times, she provided two additional encores: a fleeting and witty Debussy étude, (No. 6, pour les huit doigts (eight fingers)), and a smoky gem from Scriabin’s op. 11 Preludes (No.11 in B). Overall, a sparkling set of performances by a subtle and passionate artist.

Veritas Katharina Gassmann studied Physics, Music, and Creative Writing at New York University. She holds an M.F.A. in Literary Arts from Brown, and now pursues doctoral studies at Tufts.


6 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. This is a really beautiful review in every way. I adored this concert- what an artist she is!

    Comment by Susan Miron — April 18, 2023 at 8:02 pm

  2. I’m attending her concert at Carnegie Hall Thursday evening, partly based on this review.

    Comment by Gregory McNiff — April 19, 2023 at 12:13 am

  3. An extraordinary review! It captures, about as well as I think words can, something of Beatrice Rana’s subtle, passionate, and deeply insightful artistry. Every performance I’ve heard by Rana has been original and memorable – almost as if hearing the works for the first time – but Friday was truly magnificent. For her part, the author somehow evokes the magical spell Beethoven and Rana cast over us in the Hammerklavier’s Adagio, and the triumph of the fugal finale, in what may be the best piano writing I’ve seen. Brava!

    Comment by nimitta — April 19, 2023 at 8:01 pm

  4. Please give us more from this aptly named reviewer.

    Comment by denovo2 — April 20, 2023 at 5:48 pm

  5. I was not at this recital but after reading and just now again re-reading Ms Gassmann’s truly eloquent review I was transported from my Northern Vermont home through her colorful,intricate and learned musical detailing of Ms Rana’s performance. Congratulations to both!

    Comment by Martin Snow — April 21, 2023 at 10:04 am

  6. A beautifully written review of a beautifully played recital.

    Comment by steve wigler — April 21, 2023 at 6:04 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.