IN: Reviews

The Other Mendelssohn’s Early Cantatas


Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel in 1842

Fanny Mendelssohn (1805-1847, after 1829 Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel), the older sister of Felix, is mentioned in all biographies of her brother as an enthusiastic musician, especially as a pianist, in which capacity she joined with Felix in playing the overture to his early masterpiece, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, which he first conceived for piano four-hands and only orchestrated some years later, when he wrote the rest of the incidental music for Shakespeare’s comedy. Some may have known that Fanny composed songs and piano music, but her father and brother, while encouraging her compositional activity,  convinced her that publishing her music was inappropriate to a woman of her social class. Felix did publish some of her songs in one of his sets, but without identifying them as hers. (When Felix had an audience with Queen Victoria during a visit to London, he was forced to confess that Fanny had actually written the queen’s most favored song.

In the course of her short life (cut off by a stroke at the age of 41 as parents and brother prematurely), Fanny composed about 500 works, mostly songs and piano pieces, as was typical of women composers in the 19th century, who rarely had performance outlets beyond their own salons. Yet at a surprisingly early age of 26 (in 1831) Fanny composed three larger works for chorus and orchestra, evidently to test her mettle in a more demanding kind of work, though the performing materials were long unavailable (only recently have some large sections of her output been published) and essentially unknown to the musical world.

The relatively recent access to performing parts made possible a welcome concert of all three of these cantatas by the Capella Clausura. Amelia LeClair directs the organization that focuses on music by female composers, as well as other music that puts their works in context. This welcome show ran on Saturday, March 30th, in Emmanuel Church in Boston, and the following afternoon at the Eliot Church of Newton. (I heard the Newton performance.)

The large choral works alternated with four part-songs (for soprano, alto, tenor, and bass soloists) from Fanny’s last published work, Gartenlieder (Garden Songs), of 1846. Shortly before her unexpected death she decided to ignore the qualms of her father and brother about publishing her music, and she started a project—left very incomplete—to issue various works, mostly songs and piano pieces, under her own name. A different vocal quartet sang each of these four, thereby giving members of Capella Clausura more prominent roles. Unaccompanied quartet songs of this sort existed in great numbers at the time, with examples by Felix Mendelsohn, Schumann, and Brahms, among other less familiar names, especially for the pleasure of music-making in the home or the somewhat more formal salon, or now more increasingly to be sung by choirs. In either case, the poetry emphasizes the beauties of the world in different seasons, or nocturnal moods, the brilliance of the sun or the stars, and tender expressions of passion and yearning. These lyrical quartets offered views of Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel at both early and late stages.

The main focus, however, was on the three larger choral works. For these the chorus offered firm projection of the varied moods of the texts (mostly Biblical), linked by recitatives somewhat in the style of Bach, whose cantatas both Felix and Fanny encountered via the Berlin Singakademie.

The Lobgesang (Song of Praise) served as an expression of celebration for the birth of the composer’s only child, her son Felix Ludwig Sebastian Hensel, born in 1830, and endowed with given names that evoke his uncle as well as Bach and Beethoven. The work opens with a lovely Pastorale, which Wellesley professor Claire Fontijn suggested, in an interesting opening talk, was influenced by the second part of Bach’s Christmas Oratorio. The opening chorus (text from Psalm 62) suggests a confidence in God while waiting—for the birth of a child? R. Larry Todd, the scholar of the standard biography of Felix, has suggested that the composer herself sang an alto recitative on the pains of childbirth. And the final chorus sets a joyous chorale text by Johann Mentzer best known in English-speaking churches in the translation “O, for a thousand tongues to sing / My great redeemer’s praise.”

Hiob (Job) draws its text entirely from the relevant book of the Old Testament, laid out in three movements, with a central recitative separating two elaborate choruses. The first two movements raise the existential question: “What is man, that Thou doth make so much of him?” The final chorus is an elaborate, extended expression of confidence, with musically rich contrapuntal structures and fervent expression.

Fanny composed the largest and most elaborate of the three in response to a cholera epidemic in the summer of 1831 that took many lives. It is larger in terms of the number of movements (16), the size of the chorus, divided into eight parts rather than the four of the earlier cantatas, and the size of the orchestra, to which brasses are added for the climactic ending.

The cries of those tormented with disease colors the mood of the opening sections, with pleas for help and for release from torments. Near the middle (tenth movement) comes a chorus of mourners to a text that will strike many listeners as familiar, because Brahms used it, a quarter century later, for the second movement of his German Requiem. At this emotional point the work, turns from lamentation for the departed to an expression of God’s compassion and mercy. The cantata climaxes with a superb, extended chorus of celebration one text partly drawn from Psalm 150, with the chorus and enlarged orchestra in full array.

These three striking works by a very gifted young woman of 26 made for a satisfying program, both because of the expressive variety and range of the three principal pieces and also for the expressivity of the Capella Clausura. Amelia LeClair shaped and blended well, responding firmly and appropriately to the changing expressive texts of these mostly Biblical texts, making the case that Fanny’s voice deserves a place in the canon.

Steven Ledbetter is a freelance writer and lecturer on music. He got his BA from Pomona College and PhD from NYU in Musicology. He taught at Dartmouth College in the 1970s, then became program annotator at the Boston Symphony Orchestra from 1979 to 1997.


2 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. So sorry I could not be in town for this important concert. Hensel’s three oratorios were all published in the early 1990s, so the lack of performances by other U.S. ensembles is something I would attribute to an insistence on ignorance, rather then a lack of materials. BTW, a great performance of Hiob by the Rochester Philharmonic is available on Youtube,, and we can hope Capella Clausura will make theirs available as well. Also, it’s a curmudgeonly point, but the version of the name “Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel” is a pure neologism. After reading R. Larry Todd’s biography of her, I have come around to calling her Fanny Hensel (née Mendelssohn).

    Comment by Liane Curtis — April 21, 2019 at 7:41 pm

  2. We typically, not always, go with the program name ( ‘3 CANTATAS for chorus and full orchestra by Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel’), and strive to keep our neologisms pure regardless. Of course in that family there were additional constructions:

    Comment by davidrmoran — April 21, 2019 at 9:26 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.