IN: News & Features

Zander Takes a Measure of Tchaikovsky 4


Brady to reveal Tchaikovsky’s intentions

Something fresh and intriguing this way comes with Boston Philharmonic’s subscription concerts Thursday through Sunday. In anticipation the concert of Mussorgsky’s ‘Khovanshchina’ Prelude, Prokofiev’s Piano Concerto No. 3 with Alexander Korsantia, and Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 4, Music Director Benjamin Zander opines on his recent discoveries:

In every recording of the Tchaikovsky 4th Symphony, come to the Trio section of the Third movement, and you will hear a piccolo player playing a very fast passage which is not what the composer intended.

The reason for this universal musical mistake is very simple. Tchaikovsky was wandering anxiously from one Italian town to another, trying to banish the demons of his unconsummated 6-week marriage and an apparent suicide attempt, while working at completing his symphony. He reported in a letter from San Remo to his benefactress Mme von Meck his search for a metronome during his travels*; this evidently failed, and he was forced to send the completed score to the publisher without accurate tempi indications, though he liberally peppered his Fifth and Sixth symphonies with metronome marks—no fewer than 18 in the slow movement of the Fifth alone!

Had Tchaikovsky included metronome marks, generations of conductors would not have forced piccolo (and clarinet) players to recompose the passage. Could Tchaikovsky, that most meticulous of composers, have written something unplayable?

The third movement is marked Scherzo, Allegro. Its pizzicato perpetuo character has understandably led conductors to assume that the movement is a show piece for virtuoso pizzicatists.

The normal tempo ranges between 69 and 80 to the bar (e.g. Szell with the London Symphony). Maazel with Chicago tops them all astonishingly at 84, which means that every eighth note is going at 336. That works fine for the first part since there are only eighth notes being played – and orchestras are, of course, only too happy to show off their pizzicato prowess.

For the next section Tchaikovsky marks the tempo Meno mosso. This is usually taken at about 1/4 = 96 or 100 (or 50 to the bar), which gives time for the winds to play four 32nd notes followed by two 16ths in a single beat.

But what happens next is the problem. It returns to Tempo primo with the sprightly brasses leading the way. Even at the slowest of the usual tempos, it is impossible to play four 32nd notes in the time of a single eighth note.

Put your metronome at, say, 74, double it to 148, and then double that to 296. Now imagine playing four notes going at twice that speed.

No one can actually do that, though piccolo players the world over strain to try. At this breakneck tempo, they must unfortunately change the clear and characteristic rhythm of a 1/8th and two 16ths in order to squish six notes into the time of a quarter note, after which follow a spray of 16th notes, played so fast that they sound like rat-a-tat machine gun fire; it is virtually impossible for all of them to speak clearly.

Did Tchaikovsky really intend this? He wrote a charming description of his symphony to Mme von Meck, in which his description of the third movement hardly fits this image at all.

“There is no determined feeling, no exact expression in the third movement. Here are capricious arabesques, vague figures which slip into the imagination when one has taken wine and is slightly intoxicated. Suddenly there rushes into the imagination the picture of a drunken peasant and a gutter song. 

Click above to hear the wrong way.

Military music is heard passing in the distance. There are disconnected pictures, which come and go in the brain of the sleeper. They have nothing to do with reality; they are unintelligible, bizarre.”

Suddenly all is clear!  First the winds sing the song of the drunken peasant together (meno mosso) and then the military music strikes up (pp) in the far distance (Tempo primo). The military band, even a Russian one in a dream, would be expected to march at traditional Sousa march tempo MM = 120-126, rather than the usual tempo for this section of MM = 138-160.

The drunken clarinet, tipsy, gay and relaxed, has just enough time to negotiate the four very quick 32nds followed by two clearly articulated 16ths —all in the time of one quarter and the piccolo player might actually manage a gleeful smile as she tosses off her playful roulade—exactly as Tchaikovsky composed it.

Thus, the entire movement is transformed from a frantic (and often grotesque) virtuoso show-piece that cannot actually be played correctly by even the greatest virtuosi, into a delightful interplay of “capricious arabesques…vague figures… slightly intoxicated.” Brass bands play so softly that they appear to be in the distance; along with a drunken peasant or two – all merging in a dream.

One looks in vain for a performance of Tchaikovsky’s symphony that conveys what the composer meant in this section. Next week-end the Boston Philharmonic, with piccolo player Sarah Brady proposes just that.

I venture that there are many other misunderstandings of this warhorse.

For instance, Tchaikovsky’s description of the Finale is very far from the crass, ovation-grabbing, bombastic bluster of tradition. Russian conductors in particular, all seem to agree that it should be played prestissimo (Mravinsky’s notorious rendition has become a YouTube meme), though Tchaikovsky marks it only Allegro con fuoco, not Presto.

In the absence of the all-important metronome indication, perhaps Tchaikovsky’s touching description will be sufficient to set us right:

As to the finale, if you find no pleasure in yourself, look about you. Go to the people. See how they can enjoy life and give themselves up entirely to festivity. The picture of a folk holiday. Hardly have we had time to forget ourselves in the happiness of others when indefatigable Fate reminds us once more of its presence. The other children of men are not concerned with us. How merry and glad they all are. All their feelings are so inconsequential, so simple. And do you still say that all the world is immersed in sorrow? There still is happiness, simple, naive happiness. Rejoice in the happiness of others — and you can still live.There is not a single line in this Symphony that I have not felt in my whole being and that has not been a true echo of the soul.

Thank goodness we have the description of his true intentions in the precious letter to Mme von Meck.

* “A few more days were devoted to putting the final touches to the full score, which I shall take with me, so that in Milan I might obtain a metronome and insert the correct tempi”.

Letter from San Remo 26th December 1877


Benjamin Zander discusses the passage with piccolo player Sarah Brady

Sanders Theater on Thursday February 22nd at 7:30
Jordan Hall on Saturday, February 24th at 8.00 (with a talk at 6.45)
Sanders on Sunday at 3.00 (with a talk at 1.45)

MUSSORGSKY: Khovanshchina Prelude
PROKOFIEV: Piano Concerto No. 3
             Alexander Korsantia, piano
TCHAIKOVSKY: Symphony No. 4

Tickets HERE



3 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Hello Ben

    Hope all is going well I played timpani/percussion with you and the orchestra when it was first formed in the late 1970’s

    The fourth is my favorite Tchaikovsky work although I remember it for the exceptionally challenging cymbal part in the fourth movement. Maybe the fast tempos down the years were the problem in playing this part also.

    If you make a recording or videon of this concert I would love to obtain a copy to see how it really should be played. Thanks very much

    Bob Meehan
    Assistant Conductor/timpanist
    Cakkanwolde Concert Band
    Atlanta GA

    Comment by Robert Meehan — February 20, 2018 at 6:42 pm

  2. BZ writes: “Maazel with Chicago tops them all…”

    I thought Maazel recorded this with his Cleveland Orchestra, while Abbado recorded it with Chicago. Maybe I’m wrong?


    Comment by Don Drewecki — February 26, 2018 at 1:44 pm

  3. You are right. My slip. Maazel with Cleveland

    Comment by Ben Zander — February 26, 2018 at 6:30 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.