IN: Reviews

Wellesley Chapel Thwarts Israel’s Aviv


The Concert Series at Wellesley College presented the Aviv String Quartet on Saturday, December 10th, at Houghton Chapel, a concert that was free and open to the public.  Founded in Israel more than a decade ago, Aviv has traveled around the globe concertizing and accumulating awards from competitions and kudos from presses and audiences alike. Aviv means “spring” in Hebrew. Its members are Sergey Ostrovsky and Evgenia Epshtein, violins, Timur Yakubov, viola, and Aleksandr Khramouchin, cello.

Aviv, recently having recorded the three string quartets of Erwin Schulhoff on the Naxos label, opened with his String Quartet No. 1 composed in 1924. Born in Prague of Jewish-German parents in 1894, the anti-fascist pro-peace composer-pianist died in a concentration camp in 1942. Aviv stoutly announced the sweeping, barreling unisons of the opening Presto movement. Allegro giocoso alla slovacca perking with folk tunes and syncopated dance rhythms contained an attractive innocence all conveyed adroitly by Aviv.

The closing Andante molto sostenuto consisted of little more than two successive and prolonged textures noticeably repetitive in nature: recurring cries from isolated angular crescendos answered by a continuous weeping summoned through the interval of a minor third, plucked slowly on the cello (tears) and bowed on the viola, as in a rippling undercurrent. The very softest passages of Quartet No. 1 were mostly inaudible.

Hearing live for the first time this seldom played string quartet of a 30-year old Schulhoff writing in the post-World War I era awakened images of a time gone by, a county, a musician, another human remembered.

After Aviv’s performance of Felix Mendelssohn’s String Quartet No. 6 in F minor Op. 80, there was little doubt in the minds of listeners during the quartet’s Wellesley debut as to the its impressively wide range of accomplishments. However, in the Mendelssohn, as well as in Pyotr Illyich Tchaikovsky’s String Quartet No. 3 in F minor Op. 30, Aviv’s ambitiousness became evident. Its eagerness to inject life into each of these works became obvious. An overall restlessness, or anxiousness, pervaded. Their dependency on so detailed expressiveness detracted from the compositions’ moods, harmonic fabric, and momentum.

Nor was the space favorable to their performance. Easily 400 were in attendance, suggesting that the acoustics of the large open space would be positively affected, in particular, by a reduction in resonance. That might have been the case, at least to some extent, yet from my vantage point in the 5th row from the back of the chapel, cello pizzicatos frequently boomed tympani-like while high violin notes often rang out glockenspiel-like. Fortissimo passages rasped with the quartet’s bearing down on their bows.

David Patterson, Professor of Music and former Chairman of the Performing Arts Department at UMass Boston, was recipient of a Fulbright Scholar Award and the Chancellor’s Distinction in  Teaching Award. He studied with Nadia Boulanger and Olivier Messiaen in Paris and holds a PhD from Harvard University.


1 Comment »

1 Comment [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Would absolutely disagree with a lot of negativity and audible impressions of the reviewer, and first of all- will suggest whether this person has some clinical hearing problem, which is regular disorder of the musician his age. The sounds of the quartett were of rare quality which is only possible when musicians achieve a unity of sound rather than “matching sounds” so popular among many quartetts of lower quality. The atmosphere of the performance made the audience non audible in between the movements, and full of anticipation of the next one with eagerness only visible in cases of musicianships of highest caliber, so evident in Aviv’s quartet case, that it made me sorry for anyone not able to experience it. Though- and this is a great thing-most of the audience members were in the category of listeners that appreciate the highest standards of Aviv’s perfromance, thus-standing ovations after both Mendelssohn and Tchaikovsky quartets, after experiencing the best music had to offer-its intimacy, passion, the dynamic to unfold through the movements, and all the tragism of the Mendelssohn last quartet work. This perfromance left many in tears which a true attribute of the greatest work of art. Bravo, Aviv!

    Comment by eva kaminsky — December 25, 2011 at 5:58 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.