IN: Reviews

Magical Flute from NEC


The New England Conservatory’s production of Wolfgang Amadé Mozart’s Singspiel Die Zauberflöte at the Cutler Majestic Theatre is whimsically delightful. (I saw it on Nov. 20.) Performed in English, in Jeremy Sans’s amusing translation, the work is given a futuristic setting in which the characters appear among giant circuit boards juxtaposed in post-modern collage with ambiguous Mayan, Egyptian and Masonic shapes, lettering, and masks. The headdresses worn by the Queen of the Night and her warriors are adorned with fluorescent glow sticks, and Papageno’s orange crocs complemented his “bells” (a pair of silver gloves with similarly glowing fingertips.) In the opening scene, the Queen’s three warriors, one bearing a laser gun, briefly took the iconic stance of Charlie’s Angels. In all, the staging communicated a youthful irreverence that belied the veneration with which these young artists treated Mozart’s music.

Due to its long presence in the operatic canon, there are specific numbers and even pitches in the Magic Flute that are sine qua non to the opera’s success. One example is the height and depth of Mozart’s demands on the authoritative vocal parts. The Queen of the Night’s high F is contrasted to Sarastro’s low F; both are extreme pitches that must be hit with confidence and ease to ensure an overall balance. In her big vengeance aria, “Der Hölle Rache,” Soprano Melanie Leinbach sang her high F amidst all of her coloratura fireworks with a combination of brilliance and poise — all the while maintaining a threatening onstage presence. At the other end of the spectrum, Bass ringer Eric Johnson’s Sarastro hit his low Fs with an effortless confidence. This contrast was supported physically by Johnson’s extreme height compared with Leinbach’s diminutive build. Well done!

Tenor Michael Kuhn’s Tamino, however, had a difficult night. During the first act’s portrait aria his heroic stage presence and wonderfully clear and sweet instrument was interrupted by a slight crack. This insignificant setback compounded as it sapped his confidence and led to more difficulties later in the act. By the second act he had calmed down, but in a terrible irony he did not have much of a chance to redeem himself — Schikaneder’s (rather imperfect) libretto leaves him mute for a large portion of the second act. David Tafone’s Papageno was ribald and hilarious, his oversized body shape in the green suit exaggerating his comedic presence. His animation of a bird puppet during his entrance aria “ Der Vogelfänger bin ich ja” almost distracted the audience from his warm baritone.

However, the star of the show was Bethany Worrell’s Pamina. She sang with a gorgeous and flexible soprano that revealed a large measure of dramatic intelligence and musical acumen. Her plangent “ Ach, ich fühl’s” was astonishing. Further, the timbre of her voice was well matched with Kuhn’s tenor. In the second act finale, when Pamina and Tamino’s lines join in a brief duet, the audience got a glimpse of the bright future awaiting both of these singers.

The orchestra, conducted by John Greer, was lucid and precise without being cold. Greer’s interpretation allowed the beauty of the score to emerge even as his restraint allowed the singers to obtain the spotlight. Special credit also goes to John Cuff’s excellent lighting design particularly in the temple.  The chorus, mastered by Daniel Wyneken, was excellent when onstage, but when piped in through the house speakers it tended to overwhelm the moment.

Overall, the opera was a triumph and a testament to the talented students at New England Conservatory. When the final curtain came down and the lights came up, this reviewer noticed that the audience seemed to be made up almost entirely of students, teachers, and parents of the performers. If there is a grand secret to Boston’s music scene, it lies in the amazing quality of the student productions.

Joseph E. Morgan is a PhD graduate of Brandeis University, where he studied early German romantic opera. He lives and teaches in the Boston area.


3 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. I wonder if Dr. Morgan actually attended the Saturday, November 20, performance. Every singer he names is listed in the cast for November 20. On the other hand, the his descriptions of the performances correspond to what I heard on Friday. And Papageno was oversized only in the sense of being tall. I thought he stole the show with his comedic abilities — he definitely seemed to be having fun. And I was astounded (in a good way) at the Queen of the Night’s “mad scene.” Maybe it has to do with live performance in the house versus recorded or broadcast, but her sound at the high F’s sounded much fuller and less forced than others I’ve heard, so much so that I even wondered if the aria had been transposed down a notch or two. Brava!

    Comment by Joe Whipple — November 22, 2010 at 1:48 pm

  2. Good for you, Joe Whipple! You are absolutely correct and the date has been changed in the main article.

    Comment by Norton, Bettina A — November 22, 2010 at 3:14 pm

  3. Hey Mr. Whipple,
    I just confirmed with a member of the orchestra that the Queen’s aria was not transposed. I too think it was the moment that made it so rich. By the way, thanks for the comment! Folks like you make this a fun website to write for!

    Comment by Joseph E. Morgan — November 23, 2010 at 10:30 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.