IN: News & Features

Emmanuel Church Celebrates Institution of New Rector with Special Offering from Emmanuel Music


BMInt  interviewed composer and Emmanuel Music director, John Harbison, and the Rev. Pamela L. Werntz, who is to be instituted as rector this Sunday. The 10:00 AM regular service will include Bach’s Cantata No. 163 in English, and a motet by James Primosch.  The 3:00 PM special service of institution will feature a repeat of the Primosch. Your correspondents also recalled the Rev. Al Kershaw, Emmanuel Church’s rector enthusiastically encouraging the  founding of Emmanuel Music. The incoming rector is also deeply committed to music, especially the music of Bach.

The interview with John Harbison:

BMInt: We recall that a former rector, the Rev. Al Kershaw, presided over Emmanuel when Craig Smith conceived the idea of the special music program.

Craig was a tenor in the choir at the time. The music director faltered, radically, and Craig took over the choir. And within a few weeks, he went to Al with the idea of doing a Bach Cantata series.

He had been coming to Cantata Singers concerts — back when I was conducting, and I had just gotten to know him because he lived across the street from me. …

He got the series going in ’70 or ’71. At the first performance, Rosie [Harbison’s wife] and I both played. Jane Bryden sang… It was in a period when much of the time, the congregation was meeting at Lindsey [Chapel], very small-scale. Quite soon, I think the second year, Craig decided to do it every week. Al was fine with it.  Then Craig augmented the chorus quickly with some other singers.

BMInt: Do you think the Bach Cantatas have helped increase the congregation?

I think they did, I think Al thought they did, very much so.  Bach cantatas, and the Jazz ministry, were very beneficial.

BMInt: Al was a jazz musician, right?

No. He was not a player, he was a jazz historian, very knowledgeable … deeply engaged in jazz. … And that was part of his connection to Bach. He heard a lot of musical connections between Jazz and Bach. He supported it tremendously.

BMInt Staff Photo
BMInt Staff Photo

BMInt: At that point Emmanuel Music was not a separate entity?

Oh no. It was a long time before that. ……Very early on, though Craig also started the evening concerts, and the Mozart Birthday thing started almost immediately with the Bach Cantatas.

BMInt: How does the Cantata fit into the service?

It was meant to be part of the service…

BMInt: It must have fit into the service differently in Bach’s time…

The position of the Cantata in the service changed at various times. Even with Al. Generally the present arrangement was predominant — at the end of the service.

BMInt: There was always the debate, that some people would come to the service and leave before the music, and some would come late, just for the music.

That’s much less true now. Part of the influence of Pamela Werntz has been that people are tending to be here through the service. She has made music more relevant to the service by carefully incorporating the weekly lessons with the choice of Motet and Cantata used in the service. She also is incredibly motivational. Great sermons.

She chose a motet for the installation, by James Primosch, Spiraling Ecstatically. This is a favorite of Pam’s, on an e.e. cummings poem.

I try to find a cantata that deals with the time of the year and so Cantata 163 [Nur jedem das Seine “To Each his Own”] came into my head —”Should we pay taxes to Caesar?” We are doing it in English a translation I commissioned thru the Seattle Symphony. It’s a great one to translate because people think ‘WOW! Bach wrote about that??’

The interview with the Rev. Pamela L. Werntz

BMInt: Will Emmanuel Music stay here?

They are clearly here to stay. I have been here two years as priest-in-charge.  As of Sunday, I’m also here to stay. We have been in a period of expanding our collaboration. John and Michael Beattie, assistant music director and I have worked to integrate the text of the Cantata selections with the rest of the liturgy in the way it was intended to be,…

BMInt: Is Emmanuel Music part of every service?

BMInt Staff Photo
BMInt Staff Photo

They have summers off, and other vacations. But we have lots of musicians in the congregation, people who sing professionally in other places. Many talented musicians are drawn to this congregation because of the quality of the music. So we can assemble a talented pick-up choir.

BMInt: Do you have a musical background?

The Rev. Werntz:  I do! … I was a serious student, and I thought I would go to conservatory. I was taking organ lessons. The only composer I wanted to study was Bach, but my teacher insisted that I had to learn other music, so I quit and walked away from music… I went to a college that didn’t even have a music major. By my junior year I was bereft about the loss of music, so I learned German and took a semester in Vienna and spent the whole semester completely immersed in music. I thought that was a chapter in my life I would never use again!

The bishop asked me to come to this church because of my organizational development,  business background, that’s what they thought of…German and Bach are nowhere on my resume. What on earth, why would that matter?

BMInt: do you chant?

I do chant. I love to chant. I chant the Eucharistic prayer, the great litany, the first Sunday of Lent…For me it is important for this congregation to be fully engaged, to be empowered, to be a congregation and not an audience. Since we have been strengthening this collaboration, the number of people in this building during the worship service. has grown, say, about 25%.  The number who have come earlier and earlier during the service and stay to the end has more than doubled. People are feeling the engagement and the connection, and wanting more.

BMInt: Is it because you are making the cantata more relevant to the service?

I think so. I think it’s because, when we can connect the prayers, the concerns of the community, the sacred texts, the hymns, the Cantata, motet, whatever the choral service music, when all of those are connected, it creates a buzz that energizes the community. You feel the theme go from the opening sentences through the end of the Cantata. They all fit together. they are not all same thing, but they need to be part of the conversation, … so people leave here with more energy than when they came in. Everyone does. People who have played their hearts out, people who have sung, can carry it into whatever their week is going to look like.

BMInt: that’s what Bach was trying to do…

That’s exactly what Bach was trying to do!

See related review here.


8 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Sunday services are at 10:00 a.m.! Service of institution is this Sunday at 3:00 p.m. Please join us!

    Comment by Pam Werntz — March 5, 2010 at 1:58 pm

  2. Much appreciated is John Harbison’s mention of Al Kershaw, an unusual and energizing person who had a big part in establishing the musical identity of Emmanuel.

    What not everybody knows about Al is that he was, briefly, a TV celebrity, the Hip Priest, appearing as a contestant on a game show called “The $64,000 Question,” back in the Eisenhower 1950’s, and answering questions about jazz. I was 12, I think, when I first made his acquaintance via the tube parked in my family’s basement room.

    Comment by Joel Cohen — March 6, 2010 at 2:24 pm

  3. That integration has always been the goal, and the ideal, but it requires a lot of care; Pam does a particularly beautiful job of it.

    Comment by CTR — March 6, 2010 at 10:04 pm

  4. Re: the $64,000 won by the Rev. Al Kershaw. John Harbison mentioned it in the interview, and we recalled it; but it was outside the scope of this article. But as Joel Cohen brought it up, it is worth noting that the good reverend gave it ALL away, to an organization helping jazz musicians.

    Comment by Bettina A. Norton, executive editor — March 7, 2010 at 8:56 am

  5. I liked this article about Emmanuel, Pam, and John very much!

    And, I had heard that Al Kershaw stopped at $32,000 on that tv show – meaning he didn’t risk answering the final question – and yes gave it all away in some form to jazz musicians – he had traveled with them in the South during the 50’s, learning about the discriminatory conditions under which they lived and performed – one of the reasons he was so supportive of the Civil Rights Movement when he was at Emmanuel and pushed the church along in a very liberal theological and political direction.

    Peter Johnson, Senior Warden, Emmanuel Church

    Comment by Peter Johnson — March 8, 2010 at 1:23 pm

  6. What I remember most about Al Kershaw, post-$32,000 and post-15 minutes of fame, was his enormous bear hugs. He wasn’t really an intellectual, and his sermons were not always the most incisive, but he had an ebullient personality and a big, warm heart. Bless him!

    Comment by Joel Cohen — March 20, 2010 at 3:50 pm

  7. Could someone at Emmanuel Church tell me if this was the same Al Kershaw who was a young Episcopal chaplain in an Ohio college back in the 1950s? He or another by that name was a keynote speaker (and influential person) at a Student YMCA conference that I chaired while in college…and I definitely remember his passion for jazz. But I thought he did play piano.

    Bill, now retired (after 19 years) in Watertown after Yale Seminary and pastoral career.

    Comment by Bikll Longman — October 4, 2010 at 7:24 pm

  8. Bill,
    I think must surely have been the same Al Kershaw. Here’s a link with some biographical information:

    Michael Beattie

    Comment by Michael Beattie — October 8, 2010 at 9:27 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.